Best Italian Cafe & Pizzeria in Gatlinburg TN.

February 04, 2019

Best 8 Italian Restaurants in Gatlinburg and the Smoky Mountains

Gatlinburg is packed with fantastic restaurants offering virtually every kind of food you could imagine! If you’re craving Italian, there are plenty of places for you to visit for a tasty meal. From pizza and pasta to calzones and strombolis, there’s something for everyone to enjoy. Here are 8 of the best Italian restaurants in Gatlinburg and the Smoky Mountains that you are sure to love.

1. Taste of Italy

wine glasses toasting

If you’re looking for authentic Italian dishes, Taste of Italy is the place to go! It’s located on the East Parkway in Gatlinburg, so it isn’t far from all the fun. They usually offer a variety of specials for lunch, most of which are under $10! The quality service and food combined with the affordable prices truly make this restaurant one of the best. They don’t sell wine, but you’re welcome to bring your own bottle! The friendly servers will even uncork and pour it for no additional cost.

2. Luigi’s Pizzeria

Another one of the best Italian restaurants in Gatlinburg is Luigi’s Pizzeria. It stays open until 2 a.m. and you can even have your pizza delivered! Their famous pizza pies come with a variety of different toppings. Choose from unique creations like eggplant pizza, chicken parmigiana pizza, and more! This restaurant also offers calzones, strombolis, pasta, subs, chicken wings, and salads!

3. Best Italian Cafe & Pizzeria

True to its name, Best Italian Cafe & Pizzeria has some of the most delicious Italian fare in the Smokies. This well-renowned eatery has been in business for over 40 years and continues to be a favorite among locals and visitors alike. Save your appetite for when you arrive because their portion sizes are extremely generous! You will love their buttery garlic rolls and popular menu items like their calzones, and Chicken Florentine.

4. New York Pizza & Pasta

new york style pizza

If you’re a fan of thin crust pizza, then you’re going to love New York Pizza & Pasta! This no-frills restaurant is located in the Mountain Mall in Gatlinburg, so you can enjoy your shopping spree and then stop in for a delicious bite to eat! The slices of pizza here are very large, so you’ll have plenty of leftovers for later. Traditional Italian dishes like baked spaghetti and chicken parmesan are also served here, and there’s nothing better to pair them with than an ice cold draft beer.

5. Johnny Carino’s

Whether you’re taking your sweetheart out for a date or having dinner with the family, Johnny Carino’s is perfect for any occasion. Here, you’ll find a mix of classic Italian dishes as well as delicious, new creations. You’ve also got to try their freshly baked bread, which is served with olive oil and roasted garlic. If you’d consider yourself to be more of a picky eater, don’t worry! The design-your-own pizza and pasta options are a great choice because they allow you to customize your meal however you like.

6. Geppetto’s Restaurant

If you’re looking for dinner and a view, Geppetto’s is the ideal choice. This restaurant not only has delicious entrees, it also offers gorgeous views of Cove Mountain. So, you can enjoy a satisfying and scenic meal. Some fan-favorite dishes include lasagna, stuffed shells, and Mama Geppetto’s Pizza, which is topped with meatballs and parmesan cheese. After you’ve finished your main course, you won’t want to miss Geppetto’s cannolis for dessert.

7. Nino’s Pizzeria & Eatery

A delicious New York-style cheese pizza.

When it comes to thin crust pizza, you can’t go wrong with Nino’s Pizzeria & Eatery! If you’ve never visited before, we suggest trying Nino’s White Pizza, which is comprised of a thin layer of ricotta cheese, provolone, mozzarella, and romano. Other classic favorites include linguine and clam sauce, baked ravioli, and a rich chocolate cake to top it all off for dessert!

8. Gondolier Italian Restaurant & Pizza

At the foot of the Smoky Mountains, you’ll find some of the best Italian you’ve ever had! Gondolier Italian Restaurant & Pizza serves up fresh Italian and Greek food every day with 5 star service. Gondolier is an Italian food lover’s dream come true with fantastic oven baked subs, pita wraps, calzones, and strombolis! The food is so good that you’ll want to come back multiple times a day!

Now that you know all about the best Italian restaurants in Gatlinburg and the Smoky Mountains, you can always look forward to a great meal when you’re in town! Be sure to check out all of these fantastic eateries and save on other popular restaurants and attractions with our Freedom Fun Pass!